I just finished watching the premiere episode of Morgan Spurlock”s 30 Days. and feel compelled to spew some Wisdom.
If you don”t know, 30 Days is Spurlock”s TV follow-up to Super Size Me. The concept is for someone to spend a month in an unfamiliar situation. The debut episode followed Morgan and his girlfriend - the geeky but oddly attractive Alex - as they lived on “minimum wage” for 30 Days.
Note that I put “minimum wage” in quotes. That”s because Morgan and Alex didn”t actually live on minimum wage. They never said what Alex was making washing dishes at a coffee shop, but Morgan walked right in to an unskilled temp labor job paying $7 an hour. As he makes a big point to mention all through the show, the federal minimum wage is $5.15 an hour.
This is a significant point. For if the government says you only have to pay somebody $5.15 an hour, why would the temp labor place pay a guy walking in off the street any more than that? It”s a little thing called the market economy, a force Morgan poo-poos when he casts off The Heritage Foundation”s position that higher minimum wages will actually have a negative effect on real wages and job growth.
And while Morgan does a good job of mixing entertainment and information, the program falls apart on logic and reality. Consider:
• Morgan and Alex seeded themselves with $356 (a week”s net pay each at minimum wage) to begin their experiment. No car, no furniture and just the clothes on their back. But in reality, nobody who”s a hard-working, responsible person steps into low-wage life like this. Young people have usually lived at home, shared apartments with roommates, managed to buy a crappy used car, etc., before they”re out in the world trying to make an adult living.
• After getting his first daily after-taxes check for $44, Morgan says “I”m actually working for less than minimum wage”. Um, everybody has to pay FICA, dude. If you”re so in love with government taking care of people, don”t complain about the social welfare taxes.
• In reviewing the history of the minimum wage, Morgan says “When the minimum wage was first established in 1938, it was meant to help workers maintain the bare minimum standard of living. But since the minimum wage hasn”t been raised since 1997 - while the cost of living has gone up - the law no longer does precisely what it was meant to do.”
In 1938, the minimum wage was 25 cents an hour. In 2003 dollars, that”s $3.26 based on the CPI. And the minimum wage is $5.15. So minimum-wage workers today make 58% more relative to the cost of living as they did in 1938.
• Morgan and Alex find a “free store” run by a church where they get clothes and furniture for nothing. They are touched and surprised at the generosity of their fellow humans. What, you mean something other than the government can be used to provide support to the working poor? Amazing.
• Morgan and Alex get into a financial bind when he busts his wrist and she gets a urinary tract infection. He”s outraged when he sees his bill - which included $40 for an Ace bandage. This is the reality of a health-care system where most people (on insurance) don”t know or care what their actual medical services cost. So imagine if everybody got “free” healthcare paid for by the government. How about two Ace bandages? What the hell - doesn”t cost you anything.
• In the middle of the episode, Morgan decides to make his challenge harder by pretending to have kids (by inviting his brother”s kids up). His point is you can”t afford to raise kids on minimum wage. And he”s right. If you”re just making minimum wage, don”t have kids. How hard is that to figure out?
• Morgan sums up his experience and the trials of minimum wage earners thusly: “We”re both educated, we”re both articulate - we”re white - we”re still just getting by.” This is an appropriate wrapup to the show - his biggest load of bullshit of all.
If you”re educated and articulate, you”re not going to have to work for minimum wage. That education buys you earning power. If you”re on minimum wage, it”s because you”re not educated and articulate.
Or just because you”re pushing an agenda.